Phil,
I am afraid that we could not vote on the Director of Music Ministry tonight. There were only three voting members of the committee present which is only 1/3 of the members (I guess I don't have a vote as the delegate and Dave doesn't have a vote as Lay Leader, I didn't know that!). We had to compromise (which yes I am upset about because I, as a choir member, really want to hire Mark Biondolillo as the Director/Organist). The compromise is this:
Mark will come in this Sunday, September 5th and play the organ/keyboard and accompany the soloist (so Samantha doesn't have to do that) for both services. Regina (who was the third choice of the choir) will come in and lead choir rehearsal on Thursday September 9th and then lead the worship services on September 12th (playing the keyboard because she does not know how to play the organ) Samantha would be needed to accompany the choir second service for the anthem.
PPR will then meet at 6:00 on the 14th of September, interview both Regina and Mark (Regina at 6:15 and Mark at 6:35) as well as the three (or four) candidates for Director of Children's Minister. It can potentially be a long night.
I did have your proxy vote but Jeff felt (as did the committee) that the candidates should be interviewed.
I suppose you have the power to call a meeting prior to the 14th and we can interview and hire this week prior to the weekend but I don't know if Jeff would like that. Plus with a potential hurricane I'm not sure when we could do that. I believe that Jeff prefers Regina over Mark. The choir feels Regina isn't as experienced as Mark and :(again, speaking as a choir member) I know how much he drew from me in one 30 minute rehearsal and how excited I was at the thought of being in a choir directed by him each week. I don't think Jeff likes Mark but I can't say for sure or why I believe that to be true. Just a gut feeling.
I know that Jeff isn't feeling well. He has some issues with his Kidneys that are being looked at, potentially malignant. I didn't want to rock the boat tonight, especially since I don't have a PPR vote and we only had three present who do have a PPR vote. I believe I have failed the choir but Jeff reiterated that the choir does not hire the director, PPR does.